New York Court of Appeals Finds Seneca-Owned Company Not Cloaked with Tribal Immunity

Matthew L.M. Fletcher

Here is the opinion in Sue/Perior Concrete and Paving v. Lewiston Golf Course Corp.

An excerpt:

Defendant Lewiston Golf Course Corporation (Lewiston Golf) is an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of the Seneca Nation of Indians, a federally recognized Indian tribe. We are asked to decide whether that corporation is protected from suit by the Seneca Nation’s sovereign immunity. Applying the factors set out in Matter of Ransom v St. Regis Mohawk Educ. & Community Fund (86 NY2d 553 [1995]), we hold that it is not.

Briefs and other materials here:

A102214-196-Oral-Argument-Transcript

ASuePeriorConcretevLewiston-amic-SenecaNation-amicbrf

ASuePeriorvLewiston-app-Lewiston-brf

ASuePeriorvLewiston-app-Lewiston-Rec

ASuePeriorvLewiston-app-Lewiston-replybrf

ASuePeriorvLewiston-res-SuePerior-brf

ASuePeriorvLewiston-res-SuePerior-BrfRspAmic

Lower court materials here. My commentary on the appellate division’s reasoning applies here as well.

One thought on “New York Court of Appeals Finds Seneca-Owned Company Not Cloaked with Tribal Immunity”

  1. Pingback: Who Won Indian Law and Policy in 2014? First Round Bracket — 4 of 8 | Turtle Talk

Comments are closed.